3 min read

CISA SCuBA vs. CIS Benchmarks: Cloud Security

CISA SCuBA vs. CIS Benchmarks: Cloud Security

What Is the Difference Between CISA SCuBA and CIS Benchmarks?

CISA's Secure Cloud Business Applications (SCuBA) project provides security configuration baselines and assessment resources for cloud business applications, including Microsoft 365. CIS Benchmarks provide detailed, consensus-based security configuration recommendations for a wide range of technologies. Community banks and credit unions can use SCuBA to evaluate baseline Microsoft 365 security settings and CIS Benchmarks for additional configuration guidance. The appropriate approach depends on the institution's risk assessment, technology environment, and security requirements.


CISA, the US Cybersecurity & Infrastructure Security Agency, began an initiative to help organizations manage cloud risks with the Secure Cloud Business Applications (SCuBA) project. While there are many secure cloud configuration guides, such as CIS (Center for Internet Security), SCuBA puts a new twist on them by measuring attack patterns and measuring the visibility into them. Intriguing!

Here are some takeaways compared to CIS:

  1. Simpler than CIS Benchmarks, SCuBA is minimum viable security requirements, so depending on risk tolerance and the criticality of data in O365, you can scale back to SCuBA vs CIS.

  2. Both give scripts and a step-by-step of how to configure. While both SCuBA and CIS offer scripts to implement and audit configurations, SCuBA offers GitHub downloads for easier implementation.

  3. CIS requires email and identification information to download while SCuBA has no requirements.

  4. SCuBA has additional insights into risks, attack patterns, and visibility into those with its eVRF framework. While I haven’t walked through one completely, it’s an interesting take and can provide valuable insight into monitoring, alerting, and configuration. Here’s an example from CISA’s framework document:

Picture2

  1. SCuBA was released in 2023, and was subject to a comment period in 2022. It doesn’t have as much mileage on it as the CIS Benchmarks, which started in 2000.

 

While the SCuBA has an interesting approach for a control framework, I haven’t seen an implementation of this yet. CIS has much more experience and is a suggested replacement for the Cybersecurity Assessment Tool (CAT) by the FFIEC. However, SCuBA could complement with attack patterns and visibility into cloud applications.

Feature CISA SCuBA CIS Benchmarks

Primary focus

Cloud business application security baselines

Configuration guidance across many technologies

Microsoft 365 coverage

Specific cloud service baselines and assessment resources

Detailed Microsoft 365 configuration recommendations

Primary purpose

Establish and assess baseline cloud security configurations

Support systematic system hardening

Assessment resources

Open-source assessment tools for supported services

Benchmark documentation and associated assessment tools

Best application

Evaluating cloud configuration against CISA baselines

Evaluating additional configuration hardening opportunities

Use together?

Yes

Yes

 

How Should Community Banks Use SCuBA and CIS Benchmarks?

Community banks and credit unions increasingly rely on Microsoft 365 for email, document storage, collaboration, and other business operations. Misconfigured cloud settings can create security risks involving unauthorized access, sensitive information, and business disruption.

Institutions should consider using SCuBA and CIS Benchmarks as resources within their broader information security programs. A practical approach includes:

  1. Assess existing configurations. Evaluate Microsoft 365 security settings against applicable SCuBA baselines and CIS Benchmark recommendations.
  2. Prioritize findings based on risk. Consider the sensitivity of information, business impact, existing security controls, and potential exposure.
  3. Assign remediation responsibilities. Establish clear ownership for addressing configuration weaknesses and documenting accepted risks.
  4. Validate changes. Test proposed security settings before deployment to avoid unintended operational disruptions.
  5. Review configurations periodically. Reassess settings as Microsoft 365 features, threats, and organizational requirements change.

Cloud configuration assessments should be coordinated with the institution's IT administrators or managed service providers, while information security leadership provides appropriate risk-based oversight.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About SCuBA and Cloud Security

Is CISA SCuBA better than CIS Benchmarks for Microsoft 365?

Neither resource is universally better. SCuBA focuses on security baselines for supported cloud business applications, while CIS Benchmarks provide detailed configuration recommendations. Community banks should evaluate both resources based on their Microsoft 365 environment, risk tolerance, and security objectives.

Can community banks use SCuBA and CIS Benchmarks together?

Yes. Community banks can use SCuBA and CIS Benchmarks together to evaluate Microsoft 365 security configurations. Comparing their recommendations can help institutions identify configuration gaps, prioritize improvements, and document security decisions.

Is CISA SCuBA required for community banks?

SCuBA is not a universal regulatory requirement for community banks. It provides security guidance and assessment resources that institutions may incorporate into their information security programs based on their risk assessments and applicable regulatory expectations.

How often should community banks review Microsoft 365 security configurations?

Community banks should establish a risk-based review schedule and reassess configurations following significant changes to Microsoft 365, security incidents, new threats, or changes in business requirements. Security leadership should coordinate with IT administrators or managed service providers to ensure identified risks are addressed.

 

Strengthen Your Community Bank's Cloud Security Governance

Secure cloud configurations are an important component of an effective information security program. However, identifying configuration risks is only the beginning. Community banks also need processes for evaluating findings, assigning remediation responsibilities, documenting risk decisions, and providing ongoing oversight.

Bedel Security's virtual CISO services help community banks and credit unions strengthen information security governance, coordinate risk management activities, and prepare for regulatory examinations.

Contact Bedel Security to learn how our team can support your institution's information security program.

Here are links to the framework and information to explore:

https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/2023-06/CSSO-SCUBA-eVRF%20Guidebook-guidance%20documentV2_508c.pdf

https://www.cisa.gov/resources-tools/services/secure-cloud-business-applications-scuba-project

 

 

 

What CISA’s Updated CPGs Mean for Financial Institutions

1 min read

What CISA’s Updated CPGs Mean for Financial Institutions

CISA’s recent update to the Cybersecurity Performance Goals (CPGs) marks an important evolution in how organizations should approach cyber...

Read More
CISA’s Cybersecurity Performance Goals: A New Opportunity for Community Financial Institutions

1 min read

CISA’s Cybersecurity Performance Goals: A New Opportunity for Community Financial Institutions

The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) recently released its Cybersecurity Performance Goals (CPGs) Adoption Report,...

Read More
vCISO Questions and Answers 07: What are the different forms of a virtual CISO and how much does a virtual CISO cost?

1 min read

vCISO Questions and Answers 07: What are the different forms of a virtual CISO and how much does a virtual CISO cost?

{% video_player "embed_player" overrideable=False, type='scriptV4', hide_playlist=True, viral_sharing=False, embed_button=False, autoplay=False,...

Read More